General Discussion: Class


Show original post
HiFi
HiFi avatar

994 posts since 17/7/06

21 Jun 2011 13:04
Class isn't always directly related to income though, innit. The wealthiest man I know is also the most working class man I know.

My best friend is from a family with a much lower income than my own but he is by far the most typical middle class person I have ever met. Piano and violin lessons, tennis club membership etc.

Dasein
Dasein avatar

1414 posts since 1/11/09

21 Jun 2011 13:06
Good point ^
Jesus
Jesus avatar

5914 posts since 7/10/08

21 Jun 2011 13:57
HiFi wrote: Class isn't always directly related to income though, innit. The wealthiest man I know is also the most working class man I know.

My best friend is from a family with a much lower income than my own but he is by far the most typical middle class person I have ever met. Piano and violin lessons, tennis club membership etc.

aspirations of middle class that though, remains working class himself
deuce
deuce avatar

13155 posts since 21/1/08

21 Jun 2011 14:08
eent wrote: I think the best ones were when Jordan and Ph!l were trying to get put on working class Laughing out loud
being working class is cool though
Noble Locks
Noble Locks avatar

66963 posts since 10/7/03

21 Jun 2011 14:09
like fuck is it.
Peregrine
Peregrine avatar

899 posts since 17/6/09

21 Jun 2011 14:58
Pretty sure you can whack me in middle class…even though my rents are both immigrants with working class origins, both got degrees and masters over here, dad owned his own business until he went bankrupt in the crash, mum's a teacher, I went to several state schools but my bro and sis go to private, been all around the world on holidays pretty much every year, owned a house over here previously and own a house abroad.
eent
eent avatar

8967 posts since 25/2/05

21 Jun 2011 19:08
Jordan wrote:
eent wrote: I think the best ones were when Jordan and Ph!l were trying to get put on working class Laughing out loud
being working class is cool though

That was my point Cool

Think i was the only person in this thread trying to get myself bumped up. (going against the grain makes you cooler)
Ciaran
Ciaran avatar

883 posts since 18/4/10

21 Jun 2011 20:02
Noble Locks wrote: like fuck is it.
This, +1 and cosigned.
Don't get how anyone who's working class would think it's cool to be working class, it isn't it's proper graft. Either your the exception or you ain't working class. Obviously some people are proud of what class they come from (I am and so are all my family) but I'd fucking love it even more and so would my family if theyd had the oppurtunity to be a nice middle class family doing non physical work earning regular money in a 9-5 when I was growing up. Think most people in the working class bit would agree with me aswell?
Jesus
Jesus avatar

5914 posts since 7/10/08

21 Jun 2011 20:21
i couldn't go back to working 9-5 - in any job its a fucking ball ache grind,
HiFi
HiFi avatar

994 posts since 17/7/06

21 Jun 2011 20:27
Don't you do mental hours at the hospital though?
Hello World
Hello World avatar

12043 posts since 7/3/05

21 Jun 2011 20:33
I have worked in mixed class business for years now, and I can tell you know, not a single one of the people doing manual repetitive taks for 9 hours per day for £6 to £8 per hour are happy in their jobs or the way things have turned out for them in life.

They are struggling to get by, unfortunately most of them are just low educated people that can be basically trained or they are just fuck ups who cannot do anything harder in the day than cleaning a pipe because there lives are so intrusive and insane they cant focus on anything harder.

I wish we could pay them more but it is not economical, most of them are glad of jobs because they have some self respect and dont want to be on the dole.

Thats what I call working class, life is how it is and it will never change, its difficult and tough with unrelenting stress of money, keeping a job and providing for a family.

It is not I am being paid 45k and I am so poor because my friend is being paid £55k or life is awful because I only had 1 holiday this year.
Ciaran
Ciaran avatar

883 posts since 18/4/10

21 Jun 2011 20:37
HW knows it
Hello World
Hello World avatar

12043 posts since 7/3/05

21 Jun 2011 20:52
The sad thing is some of these guys are in their 40's and I can absolutely see no way they can live on their wages and there is no way they can ever earn any more realistically.

When I see the "feed your family of four for £50" in Sainsbury and i think that is nuts, I know exactly what it is aimed at.

I wasn't brought up on that level of stress but in terms of social climbing, my first real salary at 27 was more than my fathers after 30 years of his career. Thats is the difference between working and middle class.

I only regret being brought up in a working class family was the lack of career aspiration and drive instilled in me as mentioned above, all that was drilled into me was to just to get a decent steady career, no risks.

I would have made a great surgeon but that kind of career path simply didn't exist for me it was inconceivable, no child decides to be a doctor, the potential is supposed to be spotted by the school or the seed planted by your parents.

I have done OK now, but I was extremely lucky to be in the right place at the right time with the right skills, a 1 in a million chance.

If I followed my working class advice, I would have stayed in Toshiba for the steady career which shut down 2 years after I left.
andymakesglasses
andymakesglasses avatar

19549 posts since 26/1/06

21 Jun 2011 21:10
Hello World wrote: The sad thing is some of these guys are in their 40's and I can absolutely see no way they can live on their wages and there is no way they can ever earn any more realistically.

I worked in various factories in uni holidays as I didn't want to be in an office, and it was exactly like that in those places.

I worked in a vegetable packing factory (no homo) one summer and one of my jobs was to put two baking potatoes into a four potato cardboard tray, and the guy next to me would put the other two in. The trays were coming down a conveyor belt at ridiculous speed, literally no time to stop or think and if you hesitated for a second you'd miss the tray and the production line would grind to a halt. The guy I worked with had been doing it every day for 20 years, 6 trays a minute or whatever it was. Really monotonous work doing it for 10 weeks, never mind 20 years.
Noble Locks
Noble Locks avatar

66963 posts since 10/7/03

21 Jun 2011 21:12
i wish you wouldnt do this hw. i cringe, and im not being horrible, but i seriously cringe.
thats just 'poor people by numbers' mate.
Your are becoming a parody of yourself, you have done well, but how well?
home owner yet?
super car yet?
brand new watch yet?

sorry mate, i love you near enough to be homo, but you need to stop and have a little look around and breathe in.
Dasein
Dasein avatar

1414 posts since 1/11/09

21 Jun 2011 21:16
HW, the wise man. Laughing out loud
Hello World
Hello World avatar

12043 posts since 7/3/05

21 Jun 2011 21:23
Same in toshiba, old school production lines, worst job was the box packer, all they did was open a flat packed cardboard box from its flat position to square and open. That was the lowest job in the plant, you got that if you failed soldering or failed using a electric screw driver or component insert.

I did my placement year in university designing TV's down there and a guy was doing that job, when I went back there 2 years later he was still doing it.

I always feel terrible when I see someone working in a fast food place or the like and I go in there when on business and for instance I come back 1 year later and they are still working there (obviously I can only remember people of unique appearance) same with hotels when I am working abroad and go back to the same place year after year. I forget that is not a temp job or something during a uni break, but their life.

Some people do not even know that kind of work exists, I do feel far more grounded from doing a little and seeing that kind of work, when I make my living tapping a few keys on a keyboard and thinking of stuff.
Hello World
Hello World avatar

12043 posts since 7/3/05

21 Jun 2011 21:27
Noble Locks wrote: i wish you wouldnt do this hw. i cringe, and im not being horrible, but i seriously cringe.
thats just 'poor people by numbers' mate.
Your are becoming a parody of yourself, you have done well, but how well?
home owner yet?
super car yet?
brand new watch yet?

sorry mate, i love you near enough to be homo, but you need to stop and have a little look around and breathe in.

I said done ok compared to earning the 18k I was brought up to expect to earn. I have none of those things and anyone who does is far richer than me. We were discussing class as ambition and aspiration.

I dont even know why I am in middle class?
Noble Locks
Noble Locks avatar

66963 posts since 10/7/03

21 Jun 2011 21:30
ok, my bad. i just find it hard when people feel sorry for people when they aint got fuck all themselves.
how you know the cardbord box maker dont go home every night to a loving wife and children who love the life out of him, and he embraces every waking moment when hes not working, with his family?
do you do that, or do you just count your money and visvim items?
Boing
Boing avatar

236 posts since 16/5/09

21 Jun 2011 21:32
I'm sorry HW, you are obviously a very intelligent guy, but you can't just over these analyse things and keep coming with these sweeping statements as facts, life isn't just a set of statistics.