General Discussion: I have 15k(ish) to invest - please advise me!


Show original post
DuffMan
DuffMan avatar

13373 posts since 21/2/07

6 Feb 2012 12:13
Depends on the risk vs return you both want. Figurine if you're not a taxpayer (PHD funding isn't taxed right?) than a long-term high-rate fixed bond might be an all right bet. Otherwise putting some money in a few funds or buying stocks yourself is probably your best bet but obviously you might lose out. I've got some money about to finish up in a fixed rate bond, thinking about buying high profile, big company shares for the dividend.
JustinCredible
JustinCredible avatar

1976 posts since 11/6/08

6 Feb 2012 12:20
I sold a load of shares last week as the price had shot up and had made a lot on them so don't mind taking a risk but shares in general seems to me like the sort of thing you need to invest a lot of time into, reading up on companies etc. and I don't think I could be bothered.

Anyone know what a share isa is / how it works?
Serbia
Serbia avatar

4928 posts since 22/3/06

6 Feb 2012 13:53
JustinCredible wrote: I sold a load of shares last week as the price had shot up and had made a lot on them so don't mind taking a risk but shares in general seems to me like the sort of thing you need to invest a lot of time into, reading up on companies etc. and I don't think I could be bothered.

Anyone know what a share isa is / how it works?

who do you sell shares through? I want to open a share account just to buy and hold some big companies but i don't want to get fucked on commission. i also want to set up and run a dummy portfolio, not sure who to do it through though.

share isa is same as your cash isa, you get a cash and share allowance each year. i use mine on a HSBC tracker fund, it's not a great fund (FTSE 100 tracker), but the charge is next to nothing compared to a managed fund which in general give the same sort of return.
eent
eent avatar

8967 posts since 25/2/05

6 Feb 2012 18:09
I use investopedia for a dummy portfolio. Good resource.

I'm 17% up so far this year.
Serbia
Serbia avatar

4928 posts since 22/3/06

6 Feb 2012 18:20
Cool

Any idea who's cheapest to set up a share isa with and run an execution only portfolio?
JustinCredible
JustinCredible avatar

1976 posts since 11/6/08

6 Feb 2012 18:22
bresone wrote:
JustinCredible wrote: I sold a load of shares last week as the price had shot up and had made a lot on them so don't mind taking a risk but shares in general seems to me like the sort of thing you need to invest a lot of time into, reading up on companies etc. and I don't think I could be bothered.

Anyone know what a share isa is / how it works?

who do you sell shares through? I want to open a share account just to buy and hold some big companies but i don't want to get fucked on commission. i also want to set up and run a dummy portfolio, not sure who to do it through though.

share isa is same as your cash isa, you get a cash and share allowance each year. i use mine on a HSBC tracker fund, it's not a great fund (FTSE 100 tracker), but the charge is next to nothing compared to a managed fund which in general give the same sort of return.
http://www.shareview.co.uk/Pages/default.aspx

Only used these as I had just under 15k of shares to sell and there was a flat fee of something like £12.50 per trade rather than a percentage.
Brian Damage
Brian Damage avatar

7677 posts since 21/10/03

6 Feb 2012 18:40
worth a look here for some info. SS only worth it for longer term, 5+ yrs. look into getting more info/advice from an IFA if you're serious and want to take some risk (otherwise cash isa's/bonds, premium bonds, easy access savings acc, inflation linked savings certificates)

http://www.hl.co.uk/
http://www.iii.co.uk/

some more info here:

http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/savings/isa-discounts
DuffMan
DuffMan avatar

13373 posts since 21/2/07

6 Feb 2012 19:24
If you get a fund through one of the comparison sites or similar the fees are often v. small but yeah I was reading some thing on the motley fool basically saying managed funds are shit and that index linked funds usually end up outperforming them over time.
DesignGuy
DesignGuy avatar

398 posts since 1/4/08

6 Feb 2012 20:11
What about trading futures or short selling? was meaning to look into it @ some point.
Anyone trade casually here… If so can throw any light on the upside/downside of being a non-professional trader.

Noticed this company among others have their own proprietary platform/software.
http://www.trade2win.com/boards/futures/128094-tax-free-futures-trading-using-tt-stellar-cqg-ibetfinancials.html
http://www.kytegroup.com/execution
woffle
woffle avatar

82 posts since 19/1/09

6 Feb 2012 20:21
DesignGuy wrote: What about trading futures or short selling? was meaning to look into it @ some point.
Anyone trade casually here… If so can throw any light on the upside/downside of being a non-professional trader.

Noticed this company among others have their own proprietary platform/software.
http://www.trade2win.com/boards/futures/128094-tax-free-futures-trading-using-tt-stellar-cqg-ibetfinancials.html
http://www.kytegroup.com/execution

You'd be amazed at how many people shell out £££ for software, reading matter or forums that supposedly will show them how to make their fortune by sitting at home and trading; usually it seems to be promising money via futures or FX - last candidate I interviewed was about £2.5K in the hole supposedly to learn how to become a trader earning thousands. Didn't have a clue.

I've seen a few arcades with people making good money but they seem to be the exception rather than the rule.

We've used TT at work before - it's not cheap from memory. Weren't the hugest fans to be honest but then it's not quite the same as using it from home. I'm not allowed to have a personal trading account without serious amounts of admin but I'd look at trading via spread betting for starters. Using one of the many Mock Trading futures simulators is a good place to start…
ChrisAlright
ChrisAlright avatar

1384 posts since 29/6/08

6 Feb 2012 20:33
DesignGuy wrote: What about trading futures or short selling? was meaning to look into it @ some point.
Anyone trade casually here… If so can throw any light on the upside/downside of being a non-professional trader.

Noticed this company among others have their own proprietary platform/software.
http://www.trade2win.com/boards/futures/128094-tax-free-futures-trading-using-tt-stellar-cqg-ibetfinancials.html
http://www.kytegroup.com/execution

lol

please start "casually" trading. it's so easy to make money in the markets these days that you can profit a shitload just doing it in your spare time! A couple of contracts here, a couple of stocks there, you'll be a millionaire in no time!

Look at the futures market and tell me how many contracts you can actually afford to hold.
barrence
barrence avatar

407 posts since 21/10/09

8 Feb 2012 11:09
I work for an equity hedge fund, but I sit next to a managed futures fund, and have come to the conclusion that casual FX/Futures trading is a mugs game. These guys do it professionally and they've had a tough time this year (along with all the big managed futures houses, AHL, Aspect,…), and that's with proper risk controls, loads of bods working on alpha models, dedicated dealing desks etc. You might hear about some bloke who made a load of dosh, but that's just chance/selection bias.

What I intend to do is dial up a diversified portfolio of bonds, index trackers, and maybe alternative funds. Will aim is to pick (ideally as many as possible) funds that will offer returns with a low correlation to each other and just whack the same amount in each. Then forget about it for a few years. When I finally get my finger out and optimise my pension I'm thinking of:

20% Developed markets global equity tracker
20% Emerging markets global equity tracker
20% Global Bond
20% equity absolute return
20% cash

Perhaps could get more fancy eg could put some an equally weighted rather than cap weighted equity fund, going for a bit of a bond hedge fund. Anyone got any suggestions?
R
R avatar

12883 posts since 17/5/03

8 Feb 2012 11:11
managed fund that i'm in structured pretty similarly to that, down 8% last year Cry
Serbia
Serbia avatar

4928 posts since 22/3/06

8 Feb 2012 11:22
barrence wrote: I work for an equity hedge fund, but I sit next to a managed futures fund, and have come to the conclusion that casual FX/Futures trading is a mugs game. These guys do it professionally and they've had a tough time this year (along with all the big managed futures houses, AHL, Aspect,…), and that's with proper risk controls, loads of bods working on alpha models, dedicated dealing desks etc. You might hear about some bloke who made a load of dosh, but that's just chance/selection bias.

What I intend to do is dial up a diversified portfolio of bonds, index trackers, and maybe alternative funds. Will aim is to pick (ideally as many as possible) funds that will offer returns with a low correlation to each other and just whack the same amount in each. Then forget about it for a few years. When I finally get my finger out and optimise my pension I'm thinking of:

20% Developed markets global equity tracker
20% Emerging markets global equity tracker
20% Global Bond
20% equity absolute return
20% cash

Perhaps could get more fancy eg could put some an equally weighted rather than cap weighted equity fund, going for a bit of a bond hedge fund. Anyone got any suggestions?

How much approx would you put in overall to make that kind of a pot worthwhile? a lot I'm guessing.
ShaneB
ShaneB avatar

842 posts since 28/11/10

8 Feb 2012 11:53
I wouldn't even bother with trading - the sums you're talking about are so small that the returns are nominal once costs are factored in. Find a high interest saving accounts (not necessarily a British / European bank) and / or, protect your wealth in assets and hope for a marginal capital gain.
Serbia
Serbia avatar

4928 posts since 22/3/06

8 Feb 2012 13:35
how would you even go about opening a foreign savings account without geting stung on tax. sounds like a mission.
stelfox
stelfox avatar

8481 posts since 11/3/09

8 Feb 2012 13:40
harry redknapp joke?
Serbia
Serbia avatar

4928 posts since 22/3/06

8 Feb 2012 14:21
Laughing out loud
superbe
superbe avatar

1009 posts since 5/6/08

8 Feb 2012 15:50
Barrence talking the most sense here. I like dogs of the FTSE where you buy and sell once a year and only buy the biggest companies at their lowest point.

ShaneB talking no sense whatsoever there are no savings accounts offering above true inflation i.e. money in the bank equals loss in the UK.

You cannot save money outside UK if you live here and pay tax. Less you got fam in Singapore.
R
R avatar

12883 posts since 17/5/03

8 Feb 2012 16:11
superbe wrote: Barrence talking the most sense here. I like dogs of the FTSE where you buy and sell once a year and only buy the biggest companies at their lowest point.

genius. do you not see a possible flaw here?